Judges can reject consent orders in England and Wales if they consider the proposed financial settlement unfair, even when both parties have agreed to it. However, outright rejection is rare. More commonly, a judge will request further information or an explanation of the agreement before granting approval.
An unequal financial settlement does not automatically mean your consent order will be rejected. The court is concerned with fairness, not simply whether everything has been divided equally.
At Easy Online Divorce, we regularly help couples formalise financial agreements involving unequal divisions of property, savings and pensions. In this guide, we explain what judges look for, what happens if the court disagrees with your consent order and how you can reduce the risk of delays.
How often do judges reject consent orders?
There is no routinely published national rejection rate that tells us exactly what percentage of financial consent orders are rejected.
However, the Law Commission’s 2024 report on financial remedies describes outright refusal to approve a consent order as very rare.
It is important to distinguish between a judge questioning a consent order and formally refusing to approve it.
A judge may:
- Approve the consent order as submitted.
- Request further financial information or clarification.
- Ask the parties to explain why they consider their agreement fair.
- Arrange a court hearing.
- Refuse to approve the proposed agreement.
Receiving questions from the court does not necessarily mean your agreement needs to change. In many cases, a clearer explanation of your circumstances may be sufficient.
What happens if the court disagrees with your consent order?
If a judge has concerns about your financial agreement, the court will typically issue a document known as a general order, setting out the information or explanations it requires before it can consider approving your consent order.
For example, the judge might ask why one person is receiving significantly less of the marital assets, why pensions are not being shared or how one party intends to meet their future housing needs.
Depending on the court’s requirements, you may need to provide:
- A written explanation of how you reached your agreement.
- Additional or updated financial information.
- A supporting statement explaining why you believe the settlement is fair.
- Clarification of specific aspects of the agreement.
Once you have complied with the general order, the judge can reconsider your application.
This is different from the court rejecting your financial agreement altogether.
What do judges look for when approving a consent order?
When deciding whether to approve a financial consent order, judges consider the circumstances of both parties and the factors set out in Section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973.
These include:
- Each person’s income, earning capacity and financial resources.
- Current and future financial needs, including housing.
- The welfare of any children under 18.
- The length of the marriage and the ages of both parties.
- The standard of living during the marriage.
- Any physical or mental disabilities.
- Financial and non-financial contributions to the marriage.
- Pension rights and other benefits that may be lost on divorce.
The judge considers these factors together rather than relying on a fixed mathematical formula.
Why Form D81 is important
When applying for a consent order, both parties must provide financial information using a Statement of Information, known as Form D81.
The D81 shows the court each person’s financial circumstances before and after the proposed settlement.
It helps the judge understand whether the agreement is fair and whether both parties’ financial needs are likely to be met.
Incomplete or inaccurate financial information can lead to unnecessary delays.
Does a divorce financial settlement have to be 50/50?
No. A divorce financial settlement does not have to divide every asset equally.
Couples can agree to divide their assets in different proportions, provided the overall settlement is fair in their circumstances.
For example, a couple may agree that:
- One person keeps more of the property equity in exchange for the other retaining their pension.
- One person receives a larger share of the family home to meet the children’s housing needs.
- Both parties retain their own pensions despite differences in their values.
The important thing is that both parties understand the financial implications of their agreement and that the proposed outcome is fair.
Real case study: an unequal financial settlement
One of our previous cases involved a couple who had been together for approximately 15 years before separating.
Although they agreed to divide the equity in their former family home equally, there was a significant difference in the value of their pensions, savings and income.
Their approximate financial circumstances before implementing the agreement were as follows:
| Financial circumstances | Applicant | Respondent |
|---|---|---|
| Share of property equity | £350,000 | £350,000 |
| Savings | £80,000 | £25,000 |
| Pensions | £400,000+ | £100,000 |
| Monthly net income | £5,500 | £2,200 |
What had the couple agreed?
The applicant wanted to remain in the former family home and agreed to pay the respondent £350,000 for his share of the property.
The payment would be funded through a combination of savings and additional mortgage borrowing.
Both parties agreed to retain their respective pensions and any remaining savings.
Although the property equity was being divided equally, the overall agreement would leave the applicant with substantially greater financial resources.
Why did they agree to an unequal settlement?
The couple had discussed the differences in their financial circumstances and believed their agreement reflected decisions they had made during their marriage.
The applicant felt that she had prioritised her career and retirement savings, while the respondent had chosen a different balance between work and leisure.
The respondent understood the difference in their pension values and agreed that he did not wish to seek a share of the applicant’s pension.
Did the judge approve this financial settlement?
Looking at the financial figures alone, a judge could reasonably question the disparity between the two parties. However, an unequal division of assets does not automatically make an agreement unfair.
Our approach was to provide comprehensive financial disclosure alongside supporting statements explaining the circumstances behind the agreement and confirming that both parties understood their financial rights and the long-term implications of their decisions.
The court subsequently approved the consent order.
However, this outcome was specific to the couple’s individual circumstances and should not be taken as an indication that a similar financial settlement would be approved in another case.
The key lesson is that fairness does not necessarily mean equality, but every financial settlement must be assessed on its own merits.
What happens if a judge requests a supporting statement?
Where a proposed settlement is significantly unequal, the court may want further reassurance that both parties understand the agreement and its long-term implications.
For example, if one spouse agrees not to claim a share of the other’s pension, the judge may want to understand why that decision has been made.
At Easy Online Divorce, where appropriate, we prepare supporting statements that explain:
- How the financial agreement was reached.
- The reasons for an unequal division of assets.
- Whether both parties understand the financial implications.
- How their future financial needs will be met.
Where we identify a potential concern during our initial review, we may recommend preparing a supporting statement before submitting the consent order to the court.
This can help avoid unnecessary delays by addressing questions the judge might otherwise raise.
A supporting statement does not guarantee approval, but it can provide important context about the agreement.
What happens if the judge still doesn’t approve the consent order?
If the court remains concerned after receiving further information, the judge may arrange a hearing.
The purpose of the hearing may be to clarify the agreement, explore its fairness or establish whether both parties fully understand what they have agreed.
Depending on the circumstances, the judge may approve the consent order or decline to approve it.
If the court refuses to approve the agreement altogether, the couple may need to reconsider their financial arrangements or obtain independent legal advice.
Common reasons judges question or reject consent orders
In our experience, issues that can lead to court queries or rejection include:
- Incomplete or inconsistent financial disclosure.
- Significant differences in the proposed division of assets without sufficient explanation.
- Pension arrangements that have not been properly considered.
- Concerns about one party’s future housing or financial needs.
- Unclear property transfer or sale arrangements.
- Incorrectly drafted or ambiguous consent order provisions.
- Missing information or supporting court documents.
Problems with DIY consent orders
We regularly receive enquiries from people who have attempted to prepare their own consent orders, often using online templates or AI tools, only to encounter problems when submitting them to the court.
A consent order is not simply a written record of your agreement. It is a legally enforceable court document that must be drafted correctly and supported by the appropriate financial information.
Even where a couple has reached a perfectly reasonable agreement, errors in the legal drafting or supporting documents can prevent the court from approving it.
Unfortunately, attempting to save money by preparing your own consent order can result in additional costs, delays and the need to have the documents professionally drafted from scratch.
You can read more about these risks in our guide: Can ChatGPT Write a Divorce Consent Order?
How to reduce the risk of your consent order being rejected
There are several steps you can take before submitting your agreement to the court:
- Provide accurate financial disclosure. Include all relevant property, savings, pensions, debts and income, supported by up-to-date valuations.
- Consider both parties’ future needs. Think beyond the immediate division of assets.
- Explain any significant financial imbalance. If your agreement is unequal, make sure there are clear reasons for it.
- Use professionally drafted documents. Your consent order needs to contain clear, legally enforceable provisions and be supported by the correct court documents.
Why you should get your consent order approved before finalising your divorce
The final order of your divorce legally ends your marriage, but it does not automatically resolve your financial ties.
Finalising your divorce before securing a financial consent order can also have unintended consequences, particularly regarding pension and inheritance benefits.
We generally recommend waiting until your financial consent order has been approved by the court before applying for the final order of your divorce.
Where pension sharing is involved, additional timing requirements may also apply.
How Easy Online Divorce can help
Our fixed-fee consent order service is designed for couples who have reached a financial agreement and want to make it legally binding.
For £599, our legal team will:
- Review your financial agreement and identify potential issues.
- Professionally draft your consent order.
- Prepare the D81 Statement of Information and required court documents.
- Arrange electronic signatures.
- Submit your application directly to the court.
- Manage court correspondence and keep you updated throughout.
The court application fee of £62 is payable separately.
If you haven’t yet reached an agreement, our Guided Financial Agreement Service can help you work through your financial arrangements together.
Easy Online Divorce is an SRA-regulated law firm and winner of Alternative Legal Service Provider of the Year at the 2025 British Legal Awards.
Frequently asked questions
Can a judge reject a consent order if both parties agree?
Yes. A judge must independently assess whether the financial agreement is fair. Agreement between both parties does not automatically guarantee court approval.
Can a judge make me pay more in a divorce settlement?
If a judge considers your proposed consent order unfair, they can refuse to approve it. This does not automatically mean you will have to pay more, but you may need to reconsider your agreement before it can be approved.
Can a judge approve an unequal financial settlement?
Yes. The court can approve an unequal financial settlement where it considers the outcome fair based on both parties’ circumstances.
Do we have to start again if the court questions our consent order?
No. If a judge has questions about your consent order, the court will typically issue a general order explaining what additional information or clarification it requires.
Once you have complied with the general order, the judge can reconsider your existing application. You do not normally need to start the application process again.
An outright refusal to approve your financial agreement is different and may require you to reconsider the terms of your settlement.
Can I prepare a consent order without a solicitor?
Technically, yes. However, successfully preparing a legally enforceable consent order without specialist legal knowledge can be extremely difficult.
We regularly hear from people whose self-drafted consent orders have encountered problems at court, despite both parties having agreed on their finances.
Using a specialist consent order service can help you avoid costly drafting errors, unnecessary delays and the expense of having to start the drafting process again.
When can I apply for a consent order?
You can submit your consent order to the court for approval once you have been granted the conditional order of your divorce.
However, you can reach your financial agreement and start preparing your consent order documents before reaching this stage.
This means your documents can be ready to sign and submit as soon as your conditional order has been granted.
Ready to make your financial agreement legally binding?
Whether you have agreed an equal split or a more complex financial settlement, our experienced legal team can help you prepare your consent order and guide you through the court approval process.
Get started with our £599 fixed-fee consent order service.
About the author
James Brien is the founder and Managing Director of Easy Online Divorce, an SRA-regulated law firm specialising in amicable divorce, financial settlements and consent orders in England and Wales.
Since founding Easy Online Divorce in 2020, James and his team have helped more than 15,000 people navigate divorce and financial settlements.
Easy Online Divorce was named Alternative Legal Service Provider of the Year at the 2025 British Legal Awards.
James’s mission is to make divorce simpler, more affordable and less stressful.
